I wasn't a big fan of any of those dresses. Maybe just Penelope Cruz's.

I LOVE Marion Cotillard's dress, mermaid or not she looks unique and like oscar royalty.

love hilary swank and penelope cruz's dresses - both classy and elegant without being too much. i'm not a fan of marion's dress - it reminds me of a fish with the scales.

i like hilary swank's gown.

Marion looked amazing. The dress, the makeup, the hair -- everything worked!

Penelope, Marion, and Hilary looked sooo Gorgeous!

Penelope and Anne Hathaway looked great!

I feel like I've seen anne hathaway's gown before ... didn't kate winslet wear something similar at one of these shows a few years ago? bright red with that one shoulder of flowers?

I think overall a little "more" is okay but I'm not a huge fan of all the ruffles and such...

Marion Cotillard is drop dead gorgeous...so beautiful. I dunno about the fishscales, but the cut of the JP gauthier dress is stunning.

I loved Anne's dress...it was my favorite of the night.

I'm with Emalove. Anne's dress was my favorite, too.

Marion was just amazing....