I like MK's b/c of the belt and the Loubs!

GOSH! I'M A HUGEEEE MKA FAN, BUT I HAVE TO BE HONEST AND SAY THAT I REALLY DISLIKE THEM BOTH. I STILL LOVE MARY-KATE AND ASHLEY, BUT I'M IN AWE THAT I ACTUALLY DON'T LIKE SOMEONE THEY HAVE WORN. I USUALLY AGREE WITH EVEN THEIR MOST DARING OF OUTFITS!

P.S.-I WOULD LOVEEE SOMETHING FROM THEIR ELIZABETH AND JAMES LINE:

HINT HINT, FAB!

the shouting.
anyway, i guess this means they aren't fighting over their millions like it said in the national enquirer, just fighting over clothes.

Ashley

i like the neon and loubs and the bag!!! the bag!!

I think they both look GREAT!! I would love to own this little romper ~ and of course some snazzy threads from the Elizabeth & James line...double hint FAB!

i think its horrid but i do have to say its nice to see them re-wearing something two years later like a normal person!

both are standing the exact same way, one foot slighty pointing inwards, do they practice this?

BTW i find them both super creepy, and lost in a black hole of nasty messy fashion faux-pas

Oh I thought Mary Kate looked AWFUL in this outfit when I saw it. I'm incredulous, but it somehow manages to add about ten pounds to her tiny frame. Maybe it's the angle, the funny face she's pulling or the fact that there's way too much blousing going on over the belt, but she looks terrible!

i like the played down look Ashley has with this outfit.

I like that Mary-Kate added a splash of color. But I do wish her hair was more fun like Ashley.

I like how they both look!
Maybe MK a little but more...

I think Ashley pulls it off way better. Half because I hate the face that Mary-Kate is making. But I also like that Ashley kept it simple. I always seem to prefer Ashley's style of dressing to Mary-Kate's.

They both look like walking death. Ew.

I think if the neon pink wasn't neon pink then it would've looked better belte...

I'm going to say Ashley wore it better, but I don't like either of them. Rompers just aren't cute.

I love that they share clothes. I like it on Ashley but I think it's because of her shoes...

this would have looked cute when they were on Full House, but I think it's best not to wear a romper past the age of 5. They both look super weird.

I chose Ashley because of her laidback approach with the satin romper. But I really love MK's neon belt and her juxtaposing clutch!

And I agree with Syako, Ashley's shoes are fantastic; they offset the satin romper perfectly.

Ashley always looks better no matter want she has on.

Ashley looks bomb, although I commend them both for actually pulling off the onesie. If Mary-Kate wasn't carrying that purse it would be a notch up. Ashley just perfected it.

MK wore it better..by adding some colors to it..it looked awsome!

it looks better on Ashley, it just looks more chic to me

MK.

Honestly, I don't think very highly of either of their styles, ever.

If it fitted MK better, then she'd win. But since it's drowning on her and looks awkward, Ash wins hands down.

I like Mary Kate's add of the pink. I'd wish she smile though. =/

I like how Ashley is keeping it simple, she looks more polished.

I actually like it on both, however I think I like Ashley's hair better. I would love it if Ashley wore it with Mary-Kate's belt and her own white and pink "Victoria" Giambattista Valli platforms

though i would never be caught dead in this outfit i think that ashley wore it better. and someone else pointed out how unflattering mary kate looked in this outfit. for someone so tiny she looks really heavy and her facial expression is odd.

I think MK wore it better but it's still hard to decide.

shley!

Voted Ashley, but I don't really think either of them look that great.

They both look fab, but I voted Ashley. They seem to clean up nicely.

Mary Kate looks adorable.

Mary Kate looks adorable.

It's cute that they share clothes. Aww! Maybe Ashley left it in their home in New York and since M-K was going to a CK party, she wore it? I don't know. LOL!

Neither.

I hate both of them, and I think they both look awful. I don't mind the jumper, but I don't think it looks good on either of them - they're too short and skinny.

It's a cute piece, but something is awkward about it- on both of them. Hmmm.

the jumpsuit is to big for them

I like on Ashley. The romper doesn't need much styling IMO.

It's a bit hard to pick when one is wearing it from 2008 and one is wearing it from 2005.

Neither

don't like the outfit all that much but ona side note I ALWAYS liked ashleyy more than MK

the way MK is wearing it kinda shortens her
ashley def looks hot & chic LOVE IT

M