Quantcast
 

Would You Want a Traditional Engagement Ring?

Tue, 04/01/2008 - 11:22pm by FabSugar
7,116 Views - 76 comments

Source

on Yahoo!

Related Fab Stories

Related Network Stories


 
 
 

76 Comments Add a Comment

  • i am awesomeness's picture
    i am awesomeness
    1

    No! I hate traditional diamonds to be perfectly honest. I would honestly prefer a special ring, like with emeralds or topaz or some special design, instead of the stupid plain marquise or heart cut diamonds.

    39 weeks 6 days ago Report Comment
  • ForeverTaylor's picture
    ForeverTaylor
    2

    I want mine to be a really large pearl surrounded with some sort of small stones or a combination of different stones on a platinum band.

    39 weeks 6 days ago Report Comment
  • shannonkay's picture
    shannonkay
    3

    I have a Tiffany Princess Cut solitaire in Platinum and I love it. It's really sparkly.

    I love pearls! They're my birth stone and I often thought I'd like to have a pearl engagement ring.

    39 weeks 6 days ago Report Comment
  • AMcF's picture
    AMcF
    4

    Never thought I'd be a "diamond engagement ring" kind of gal. In fact, when he proposed with one in hand, my first question was "But, can I wear it with jeans?"

    Still can't quite make eye contact with it - the sparkly throws me off - but love what the ring represents personally: the love and heartfelt effort that went into his choice. (In fact, I later got to see the notes and research he'd done picking it out!)

    To me, this ring is way more than bling. Which, I suppose, is the way it should be.

    (BTW, it was officially paired with a "not so standard" but complementary wedding band 6 months ago.)

    39 weeks 6 days ago Report Comment
  • tiffanysophia's picture
    tiffanysophia
    6

    Classic round 2.5 carat solitaire, 6 prong platinum setting. Same as my mom, same as my grandma (well not as big as hers!). Classic and elegant, exactly what I wanted!

    Although I do love antique rings.

    39 weeks 6 days ago Report Comment
  • carhornsinapril's picture
    carhornsinapril
    7

    mine looks vintage in design -- i got a few questions about whether or not it was. it's the opposite of what i would have picked for myself (my tastes skew very simple), but it's perfect, and i love the thought he put into choosing it for me.

    on the opposite end, i saw an absolutely fabulous ring with and uncut diamond & a hammered gold band in a wedding magazine, and fell for that, so i guess i'm all over the place, taste-wise!

    39 weeks 6 days ago Report Comment
  • Tullia's picture
    Tullia
    8

    I'd like a colored diamond..or a different gem stone. Anything is fine really though, if he chose the ring w/his heart.

    39 weeks 6 days ago Report Comment
  • dreamlover823's picture
    dreamlover823
    9

    I have one round 1 carat with side stones as my original engagement ring (it came with a matching band) but Im not big on the whole "it has to be a diamond" thing sooooo throughout the past few months I have bought colored stone rings, cubic zirconia wedding sets, sterling silver solitaires with matching bands, etc. Its fun to switch it up. Smiling I LOOOOOOOVEEEEEE jewelry!

    39 weeks 6 days ago Report Comment
  • bbkf's picture
    bbkf
    10

    Hubby picked mine out on his own and did a wonderful job- 1.5 carat white diamond, emerald cut, in a platinum band. It's classic and beautiful!

    39 weeks 6 days ago Report Comment
  • thorswitch's picture
    thorswitch
    11

    My husband and I got married about 14 years ago, and pretty much everything about our engagement and wedding was non-traditional. We didn't want to spend a lot of money on the wedding, partly because we didn't have a lot, and partly because that's just not our style. So when it came to an engagement ring, even though his parents offered to give us the money for a diamond ring, he surprised me with a beautiful onyx cabochon set in a silver oval on a wide silver band. I think it ended up costing him all of about $25, but that didn't matter - it was exactly the kind of ring I'd pick for myself.

    39 weeks 6 days ago Report Comment
  • emalove's picture
    emalove
    12

    I do have a traditional-style engagement ring. Tiffany setting, white gold, 1.2 carat round solitaire. Love it. Simple and stunning.

    I would have liked whatever ring he chose for me, but I'm glad he went with what I wanted.

    39 weeks 6 days ago Report Comment
  • javsmav's picture
    javsmav
    13

    I want a lab made diamond b/c I don't want to support the diamond industry. I also think expensive jewelry is a waste of money. I'd rather have shoes.

    39 weeks 6 days ago Report Comment
  • nuri's picture
    nuri
    15

    My engagement ring is a small blue sapphire, ina tension setting in a titanium band. I adored it, but I only wear my wedding band now -- a titanium band with a blue inlay.

    39 weeks 6 days ago Report Comment
  • Lovely_1's picture
    Lovely_1
    16

    I want a traditional one!
    BUT I might take a caranry diamond too...yesterday i saw a GORGEOUS one on here and would have loved to have that one!

    39 weeks 6 days ago Report Comment
  • LaFemmeFatal's picture
    LaFemmeFatal
    17

    I have the best of both worlds. A 3.0 ct Tiffany Legacy. Classic, but still amazingly detailed and vintage looking.

    39 weeks 6 days ago Report Comment
  • aimeeb's picture
    aimeeb
    18

    Two things I require:

    -white gold or platinum
    -emerald cut

    I hate any other cut and despise yellow gold.

    39 weeks 6 days ago Report Comment
  • SkinnyMarie's picture
    SkinnyMarie
    19

    I have what I have. It was a gift, and looking at it reminds me of my fiance. I don't know how big it is, or any of that crap. That isn't important in the long run.

    39 weeks 6 days ago Report Comment
  • abqmama's picture
    abqmama
    20

    I have a 1 carat emerald cut white diamond on a platinum band. It's beautiful and I love it.

    39 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • brittanyk's picture
    brittanyk
    21

    I love my ring. It's a 2.5 carat round stone, set with 4 small side stones on each side in white gold. I originally thought I wanted something untraditional, but I ended up with a traditional ring and I love it Smiling

    39 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • sashak's picture
    sashak
    22

    I picked other

    I'm having my grandmother's engagement ring & wedding band made into one ring & I'm using my grandfather's wedding band as my band. The diamond is itty bitty but I don't care at all b/c the rings are such a part of my family.

    Plus Mick & I are broke & if he spent a sh*t ton of money we don't have on some ring I'd kill him

    39 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • melizzle's picture
    melizzle
    24

    I always wanted a vintage style ring. But my husband had his great grandmother's stone reset into a fairly classic setting, with unique side stones and pretty filigree design. It's better than anything I could've dreamed!

    39 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • KansasNutmeg's picture
    KansasNutmeg
    25

    I let my fiance pick it out! So many of my sorority sisters picked theirs out and it really took the romance out the whole thing. (1) because a lot of their picks were over the budget for their men, which made for a lousy proposal and grumpy guys and (2) they already knew the proposal was coming so it wasn't much of a surprise.

    Im lucky though...i love my ring (1.5 tiffany round setting with baggettes on the side)...i often wonder what i would have done if i had hated it. The other thing i love about my ring is knowing that he picked it out just for me. I honestly wouldn't have picked this ring out if i was picking it, but i love it probably more than what i would have picked.

    Side...I AM picking out the wedding ring. Which I plan on wearing alone...so its like two rings, somedays i will wear my engagement ring and other days my wedding band! Double Bonus!

    39 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • maggieleigh's picture
    maggieleigh
    26

    We picked it out together (and split the price - I was working and he was finishing up school). Ended up with a 1 carat marquise cut diamond in an antique setting with pave diamonds - band is similar, each have the diamonds only halfway around. It's perfect, beautiful, very classic looking, and we both love it Smiling.

    39 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • littlebmac's picture
    littlebmac
    27

    My fiance gave me some of ideas that he had looked at. I was so touched by his interest and input for the engagement ring. It was really sweet. He got me a beautiful platinum diamond ring and I love it. It doesn't matter to me what carat it is. I love that it came from him and to me, it represents our new chapter in our relationship.

    39 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • julieulie's picture
    julieulie
    28

    I LOVE my ring. It's an asscher cut, so it's a traditional ring but asschers are apparently rather rare, so it's definitely not the same thing that is on everyone's finger, which is the feeling I get with round cut (I've actually not met anyone in person that also has an asscher, but everyone who sees my ring loves it so much that they want one for themselves!). The only thing I wish I could change is that mine is a center stone with side stones... I'd actually rather just have a solitaire, if I could change my ring. I think the side stones will compete too much with my prong-set asscher eternity band.

    39 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • bvfashion's picture
    bvfashion
    29

    I don't want a traditional diamond ring, because I'm against the diamond industry. I don't blood to be shed so that I can have a ring. I would rather have a different stone, and know that I am doing a part in boycotting the diamond industry. Every little bit makes a difference.

    39 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • curli's picture
    curli
    30

    Um, I don't really know if I want an engagement ring. I'd like a wedding band, but I don't feel the need to have my boyfriend fork out major dollars to prove the love I already know he has.

    39 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • vanprooyen's picture
    vanprooyen
    31

    My ring is traditional but different. Like Princess Diana, I have a 7 carat Ceylon sapphire with 1.2 carats of diamonds on the side in two half moon. So many compliment me on how beautiful it is, and how nice it is to see someone with something other than a big diamond. But some diamonds are beautiful. I particularly like the Tiffany Legacy ring because it looks vintage.

    39 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • bbkf's picture
    bbkf
    32

    bvfashion- many Canadian diamonds are certified as ethically mined.

    39 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • Dana18's picture
    Dana18
    33

    I got to pick out my engagement ring, it is platinum with a
    emerald cut diamond.

    39 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • Nicwolf's picture
    Nicwolf
    34

    I love vintage jewelry and stones of all color, but I would be happy with whatever my guy picks out. He knows my taste and style well enough to pick out the best ring (hopefully)!

    39 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • christina b's picture
    christina b
    35

    I belong to the rare breed of girl who doesnt like wearing jewelry, its like pet peeve, so I'd prefer something very untraditional - perhaps not even a ring at all

    39 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • nevaeh1978's picture
    nevaeh1978
    36

    Mine is a solitaire, diamond ring, round cut with a gold band.
    Pretty 'traditional' or generic.

    39 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • Jack D's picture
    Jack D
    37

    I'm not trying to be rude, but wasn't the question what type of ring do you like? not what was the size of your engagement ring.

    39 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • gabiushka's picture
    gabiushka
    38

    My engagement ring is perfect for me. Beautiful and simple and it makes a statement.

    39 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • anna_muffin's picture
    anna_muffin
    39

    I don't wear jewelry (hello there, christina b), so my fiance made me the perfect engagement ring out of two differently colored pieces of wood. It's completely me. Now my (seven years older) sister is making a wooden engagement ring for her boyfriend. I guess we're pretty untraditional (and low maintenance Eye-wink )

    39 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • amila44's picture
    amila44
    40

    I'm fairly traditional. We picked out my ring together and used the diamond from my mom's engagement ring (she is widowed and doesn't wear it anymore and wanted me to have it.) We also used 4 side stones from a ring that my grandfather owned. The design I picked out is very similar to my paternal grandmother's ring, so all in all it's a little old-fashioned, very classic and very meaningful to me because of the history and love that the ring is built out of. I love it!
    And on an unromantic note, we couldn't have afforded much without having had the stones already. I plan on getting a simple white-gold wedding band. I don't like chunky or bulky jewelry.

    39 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • secrethoughts's picture
    secrethoughts
    41

    My engagement ring isn't traditional per se, but I wouldn't call it super individual either, but it's absolutely gorgeous, and my husband picked it out himself! For the record, it's a three diamond ring with a white gold band with a Tiffany ribbon-style setting. Love it!

    39 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • onabanana's picture
    onabanana
    43

    I have a traditional ring round solitaire in platinum...It's pretty but I don't love it...Shocked( Oh well....what can I say...nothing. Shocked(