Maggie and Anne were close seconds for me...but the red lipstick paired with nicole's dress was PERFECT.

Anne, then Nicole.

Kirsten looks terrible. The red is just ok on her, but her foundation is disgusting!

Gwyneth all the way!!!!!!

Something is very wrong with Kirsten Dunst. She has a great figure: why is she always dressed like a rag doll?

-the ceeg

None of em.

Definitly Anne! With Nicole and Maggie close behind! I think Kirsten was a huge miss!

Nicole

Rachel looked old Hollywood stunning. I thought she wore it best.

Anne, then Nicole

Maggies lips by far...Anne's are barely red

Anne even though they aren't really red

Kirsten and Rachel's lips are too dark and harsh, imo. Love all the rest, with Nicole as my fave.

Anne and Maggie.

Nicole

Maggie, then Nicole.

Anne. We've seen it on "The Devil wears Prada", red lipstick compliments those dark eyes and hair.

Rachel

**“In my mind, I’ve always been an A-list Hollywood superstar. Y’all just didn’t know yet.” -Will Smith **

Anne and Gwyneth look the best, Rachel looks the best in "burgandy" though
_________________________
Cheese It!!

i think anna's lipstick looked great but it isnt really red. nicole's was definetly the best, it looked amazing with her gorgeous dress. rachel is a close second.

Anne, but Nicole is a close second. I'm not a big fan of the red lips, but Anne's lips weren't too red, and Nicoles's matched her dress perfectly.

I thought it looked awful on Kirsten though.

I think Anne is the only i like!

Nicole was stunning, my favorite on the red carpet.

~live well... laugh hard...~

they're all working the red lips except for kirsten!

Maggie's "b*tch red" works the best with those sparkling blues eyes.

When it comes to red, there's RED and then there's red. I tend to go for the former, and if it ain't like that, avoid red altogether and go with something different.

If you can't pull off b*tch red, then sorry, it's just not for you.

Anne Hathaway's lipstick is good!

Anne is the best to me. I don't like shocking red with a shocking red outfit. It is a fight between your lips and the outfit for focus. I like the silver dress on Rachel, but her lipstick was almost muddy. She needed the right red for her beautiful complexion.

Nicole would have been #1, but her hair color is not right. She looks washed out. She has naturally curly hair and this bone straight hair look is very severe on her with the reds fighting for attention. It's a slight miss. With a little bit of refining, her look would be just right. She has so many things that are just stunning to look to view.

toss up between gwyneth and maggie for me. they're both naturals for red lips.