SJP can do no wrong to me! She works everything. *jealous*

I can't believe you would even include Heidi in the same post as SJP. Sacrilege!

oh heidi, why are these people even featured on sugar land?

I agree with Syako - Sugarland should be Pratt and Montag-free (and NO LC either, in my opinion).

That said, Heidi's sandals just don't look right with the black at night. And SJP can pull of (nearly) anything!

You ladies are sooo right!

Eeew! They both look OK, but in my opinion ALL gladiator sandals should be burned! lol

Is this really even a question?!?! Obviously SJP!! Love her

SJP has a complete bad a#$ outfit put together. Heidi on the other hand can't pull them off so effortless.

i also must say that I agree with Syako as well - why oh why are you featuring heidi-ho and spencer on sugar? can't we just make that stop.

SJP ALWAYS trumps Heidi. I dont care if she was wearing a brown bag with it. Psh.

It just looks better on SJP, I think it's because her leg is more delicate and provides better juxtaposition to the shoe which is kind of clunky. On Heidi, it just looks stumpy.

Lets be reasonable: Between the texture of the blouse, skirt and horrible silver bag, the shoes just end up making it as if Heidi was in a hurry and the shoes were the first ones she grabbed. SJP's is not my style but it definitely works better.

What Heidi wore was not a cool outfit, she looked confused and has no sense of style. Love SJP

Heidi's outfits are all the same. Skimpy skirt, tiny top, and high heels. She's like a Vegas showgirl during the day. And she has absolutely NO value in this world. Please remind me what she even does? Her job at that PR firm is definitely fake.
Agreed, this should be a Heidi/Spencer free zone. Everything they do is for attention, they don't care if its bad, they just want attention.
And there are few things that SJP doesn't rock at.

you CAN NOT even compare these two people.

I agree with Glmourgasm, above!

Sarah Jessica all the way.

SJP

Oh Fab, why are you keep featuring Heidi in your posts ? She's just worth the attention About the question, there is no competition here, of course SJP wears them better.

I know SJP's outfit is kinda out there, but HELLO when you're wearing Balenciaga you better make it a statement!

I meant "just not worth" sorry

SJP is in a TOTALLY differnet catagory then that Hedai chick

Wow, I had seen both these photos before. When I saw the Heidi one I though "Ew, those shoes look terrible on her. When I saw the SJP one I was like "Wow, I want those shoes!" Heidi makes everything look really trashy. I didn't even know they were the same shoes till now.

SJP!!

I want those shoes! man..i want those shoes..

SJP looks natural, love how she put it together, so effortless... Heidi looks like she is trying too hard, although it's a nice outfit, as usual the clothes are wearing her.

SJP. No brainer.

Ok the shoes are so fierce and so is SJP; Heidi, so not fierce! she is so trashy and stupid! I can't even believe she had enough fashion sense to wear those sandals.

SJP this is no contest! heidi's outfit looks so sloppy.

ughhhhhhh heidi just give up...

Sarah Jessica gets my vote for this one!! I love the entire outfit she has on-- it's quirky, funky, mismatched and adorable!! Heidi, on the other hand, just looks a hot mess to me. Not quirky, not funky, just wrong wrong wrong (can you tell how much I enjoy her!??)

Eww. Gladiator sandals are just horrible in my opinion...

SJP!!!

PS: Syako, did you ever find out the link between Sugar, Inc. and Viacom?

Even though I think gladiator sandals are totally fug, I have to say SJP looks better. Heidi's outfit is hideous & unflattering! Only certain people can wear high-waisted skirts & Heidi is not one of them. Her gross outfit doesn't even go with sandals.

It's total fugness on both.

Personality aside, I'd say that sandals look better on SJP's outfit. But that sandal is definitely not my 'bag' baby.

I agree, linds. Yuck @ gladiator sandals.

SJP -i want those shoes

Don't like either.

tia, no I have not! But your reminder has given me the desire to dig some more!

Fab has to have LC. Geez. I'm saying neither. The shoes don't work with those outfits.

SJP looks a mess and those shoes look a mess.

I can't believe you would even include Heidi in the same post as SJP!!!! Gag!
Heidi is doing so well as a 3 min reality 'star' cum 'designer' that she is wearing high fashion?
I prefer SJP outfit because simply she has the personality to carry off the whole outfit. The jacket is casual chic, and the sandals is an interesting touch.

On heidi, she dresses way too old for her age! she is trying soooo hard here, poor girl.

I love SJP's outfit!!!

I have no clue who Heidi is, but I voted for her. This isn't a popularity contest - it's about what works.

Gladiator sandals are very hard to pull off without looking totally ugly. Personally I would never wear them, even though I have skinny ankles. BUT Heidi does it right - this type of sandal needs a shorter hemline.

Otherwise, you get the SJP look - chunky frumpy legs. We know SJP isn't fat. But her legs look fat and dumpy.

The rest of SJP's outfit is quite cute and quirky, but the sandals just look yuck, and it's simply because her hemline is a few inches too long for those gladiators.

Shorten her hemline a tad and I may have voted SJP instead.