You have to give it to Diane Keaton, I mean she actually doesn't look like Annie Hall. That is a huge step up for her!!!

I actually like both of them

Diane. She looks great.

Diane looks so classy.

Very Carolina Herrera...way to go Diane! (Don't worry Sarah, I love you too).

Diane Keaton

Diane Keaton looks amazing..i love how she embodies her age and wears classic pieces

Neither - it's awful, IMO!

i think diane looks great- very classy but fun

Hands down Diane Keaton!

Silverman always looks so skanky.

It's a little overwhelming on both of them.

Silverman!
Wow! She looks classy BUT sexy

Both, i like the two different approaches.

Diane but then again I think that skirt is horrible so...

both

I must be the only person who's sick of seeing Diane Keaton in a wide belt every time she appears.

I love Sarah Silverman... the girl could wear just about anything and it'd work because of her goofy personality.

Those gloves... my god...

The skirt looks better on Diane Keaton. Love it with the white shirt and belt.

Dane pulls it off way better love her look.

Please excuse my spelling I ment Dinae.

classy always triumphs over trashy

^hahah u meant DIANE...foxy...not that it matters

I'm feeling Silverman's approach better. Don't get me wrong, Diane is definitely classic but I'm in a funky stage so Silverman gets my vote. She might have been better off with a pink shoe and pink gloves with white polka dots or something. It's needs a splash of color.

Diane looks classic...but boring. Sarah's gloves are iffy, but her shoes are cute and I dig the hair. I wish they both would've added a pop of color.

Diane Keaton is such a class act. She looks fab in this outfit. I didn't hate the other one but there is something about the white shirt and patent that stands out.

both...but im lovin sarah's cleavage

I like Diane better but agree that she looks the same every time! I think the cleavage on Sarah is way too much and not sexy but trashy! I also wish they had added a lil bit of color...

Diane Keaton must own stock in the crisp white shirt-making business...

They both look nice though.

Sarah's cleavage is hot! I'm so used to seeing her in tees that it's nice to know she can work what God gave her when necessary.

I'm loving Diane's '50s-esque spin on it; she's one of my fave icons.

Diane rocks that skirt; she looks very chic & fun.

sarah's gloves clash with the skirt. the skirt is also a bit youthful for diane.

Diane looks lovely!

Keaton, very classic.

Diane looks better. Sarah looks a little too skanky. She's showing too much cleavage and her eye makeup has is too "just been sexed" for me.