that vest is horrid

FUG.

That vest is horrible.

Umm... I like it.

I don't like it all. It looks like a scarf on Margherita.

That vest needs to be thrown out.

HORRID dress...
But I think Margherita pulled it off better between the two.

i dont like it... but i think it looks good on ashley

not feeling it, but it looks WAYYYY better on ashley

I think it looks better on Ashley because she has her hands cinching it up at her waist in the picture, making it look less gigantic and boxy. Some sort of belt maybe would help? Plus it is really, really busy so the addition of the patterned dress and accessories on Margherita just makes it way too much.

I also kinda think it looks like it was made from variously colored gum wrappers...

Fug galore.

It looks like a shapeless piece of crap a kid might cobble together to wear for a school play.

I'm not a fan, but I'll say Ashley.

Not a fan of the vest either, but Ashley wore it better.

I hate Ashley...but she wore it better

"Yuck" says it all.

I chose Marguerite but really neither did it justice.
White is the wrong color to wear with that strong a piece. and if the size was correct perhaps both would have been better. Belted would look good too. But, quite frankly, I don't think those Olsens' ever look good.

the vest looks like it's been bejewelled with glamstones. On Margherita it's swimming though accessories. I don't particularly like it, but Ashley pulls it off because her look is simple and balanced.

why not just make the vest into a dress, put a belt on it and call it a day? it would have looked better that way!

ashley looks cuter. it looks more pulled togehter cinched.

is NOT a very nice vest....but ashley looks better than margherita in it....

I guess I'm just not an Olsen fan.

i actually like the vest, i wouldn't wear like they do but i really think ash looks better

I would have liked Ashley's better if she had left it open as well.

I like Margherita. The way she wears it makes it look sooo pretty!

I usually love Margherita. But she over did it with the scarf and the embellished dress

i picked ashley, but only because its the first nice picture of her ive seen in years

Sorry, Missoni fans, but this vest would only look good over a two-piece on "'Belly Dancing' with the Stars".

something about this vest reminds me of gustav klimt's the kiss

They look identical to me...?

I chose Ash but you know, the vest is really terrible!

wtf, ewwww!

I like it a lot, but not as a vest. It should be made into a dress, and I would TOTALLY wear it (most of you probably think I'm crazy, but I love crazy stuff like this). So, while I don't like it on either of them, especially the way they wore it over a long sack dress, I picked Ashley just because she's cinching her wai ithatst so t doesn't look like a paper bag...

Margherita. I love both however Margherita's outfit is more my taste.

Not a fan of the vest, but if i had to chose it was Ashley.
But it could also depend how you wore it, maybe try it with some jeans??

not appealing. but ashley carries it off

I LOVE that vest. I'm probably the only one here!

Margherita should've worn it with denim cutoffs or something else sexier to show off her olive skinness and complement her hair..

Simplicity suited Ashley but I'd personally play around with it more. Oh only if......

I chose neither cuz it looks hideous but still think Ashley looked better with it.

Ashley looks like she's playing dress-up in her mother's clothes.

Like it better on Ashley, because belting it in gives it some shape and life.

Just draping it over another loose item seems ill-thought out and does not benefit Margherita's shape in any way...in her case the outfit would look better without the vest at all, I think the dress is cute but wasted on this look!