This dress is beautiful!!

I love the dress, I couldn't pick between the two. I think Selma looks more put together in the all around sense, and I think Kate looks like she smells like dirty gym socks except for the dress fitting her fabulously.

Kate's legs scare the sh*t out of me so Selma wins by default.
I like the shorter hemline, but I like the cleaner more out together look for this dress as well. So some combination of both would best tickle my fancy.

Selma has the charm for the dress and Kate has the legs. I couldn't decide either.

Oh! Thank you, Fab for posting this. I've been searching to find out who designed this dress. I want it SO BAD!
Kate rocked it better.

Hate the dress

Posh was also photographed wearing this dress in a club in NYC I think...

talk about ugly ... and these two women (with a zillion dresses to pick from) chose it. it's like a bad flashback to the 80s. there are so many UGLY things out there these days ... can't designers make something pretty? why does ugly now a days get termed "gorgeous"?????

Cute dress and I liked both the vintage vibe and the sexy look, but I chose Kate because I don't like Selma's bob. It looks a little Willy Wonka and falls at the wrong spot on her face. Poor Kate's legs do look weird.

I don't like the dress, but Kate wore it best.

I think that in a "Who Wore It Better" post, Kate Moss would always win. Selma looks pretty though.

victoria beckham!
she wore this too

Selma looks pretty in that dress , more then Kate , i mean.

wow Kate looks like Brigitte Bardot there.

Kate looks amazing.

sundaygreen you read my mind!!

Whats with Selmas hair? thats why I chose kate, and her shoes.

I think Selma pulls off the dress better overall, plus the retro look really pulls the best out of the design.

Kate. She has better shoes, too. Her posture is much better.

Selma looks alright. She chose a baggier fit. And in my opinion, her posture is somewhat sloppy. Again, in my opinion, the whole look is less flattering on her.

I hate to say it but Kate. Selma looks like she's drowning in the dress. It's too covered up and too big.

Yes i say victoria! she wore it too hehe

I love both, but Selma's shoes are better.

It's just amazing how different a dress can look...

love the dress on Kate until you get to her legs... they look scarrry

Vicky B wore this quite some time ago as well...

Selma wore it better.

Kate is overrated. Blehhhhh.

Kate.

Can someone please please tell me who made Kate's shoes?

Kate wears it better

I'm with Hightechlipgloss...I can't decide. They both pull it off, for different reasons.

I actually like Selma - Kate's face is wierd and she is just wayyy too skinny, although what I do love about her is that (as always), she looks like she just threw it on - it looks so effortless whereas Selma looks like she's trying for a look. I love the dress though - I want to marry MJ!!!!!!!!!

Wow you prefer Selma's face to Kate's?! She looks mean to me.

BUT I honestly haven't liked her since she was that be-yotch on Legally Blonde.

cute dress..!! KATE