I don't really like it on either of them, but it's especially unflattering on J. Lo.

I know I'm a woman and its expected of me to accept the fact that post pregnancy body never jumps right back to the old body, but DAMN! Jenny look horrible nowadays!

cam looks really cute! i think it would've looked better if jen left her hair down

She looks horrible? Really, I don't see it. I think Jennifer looks better. I normally prefer Cam, but the red lips and ponytail make Jennifer look a lot more fresh and youthful. The dress is kind of bland to begin with and it looks even more so on Cam.

I think J.Lo looks like a little girl dressed up for Sunday School. Cameron just looks more natural or something.

yeah i'm not seeing how jlo's looking horrible, but cameron diaz looks about 60

in that dress, i mean.

Neither, this dress isn't very flattering nor is it the typical style that is fitting for either of these two. If I had to choose, probably Cameron, since she has a better body.

I love the whole look on Cameron, the scarf/wrap just looks fab with the dress.

J.Lo went wrong when she put those earrings on. The dress doesn't fit her as nicely either, but the earrings...yikes!!!

Diaz looks quite the lady and those shoes ROCK!!!

Wow! I didn't recognize JLo at all! I chose "neither" because Cameron's pashmina looks way too prim and proper but I also dislike JLo's shoes and earrings with that dress. Of the two, the dress looks more natural on Cameron (although I don't think she has a better body just because she's skinnier--I'd rather have JLO's butt than Cameron's!).

I think this dress looks better on Cameron. I didn't even recognize JLo, that red lipstick is not so flattering on her. And the dress does nothing for her figure.

Cameron. JLo looks a little too washed out for this dress.

i dont like the dress--- but im going to choose cameron!

I chose Jennifer because I think Cameron looks too matchy-matchy.

I think the dress with scarf looks better on Cameron but don't like her matchy-matchy red shoes. The neutral shoes on Jennifer look better.

I mean god how dare J.Lo not overwork herself to get her pre-baby body back for all the complete strangers that feel free to nitpick her. The nerve of her I mean really. /sarasm

Personally, I think Cameron is way too matchy-matchy and Jennifer accessorized it very well. Is it very flattering for her body? Nah. But she looks just fine to me.

I don't care, it's my opinion... So calm the hell down damn!

cams shoes and scarf are nicer accessories, the neutral colored shoes make JLo look washed out...

i have to say, cam looks like shes checking into a retirement home, and jen looks like shes ready for her first day of school.... but i have to pick, jen is a little better...

JLO wears it so much better than Cameron does.

I have seen jennifer's pic on Dlisted and the dress was all open and messy from the back..and it doesn't do her any favors either, besides, she's a friggin' Diva, and says she does not want her kids to 'repeat their clothes' WTF??
I can imagine her with her voice sayin it!

definitely cameron! i think she can pull anything off... this outfit is like her character in my best friend's wedding.. very prim and proper..

the both look beautiful in my opinion

How flawless is that?
http://popsugar.com/gallery/550521?page=0%2C6%2C0

Cameron weas it so much better.

I love JLO =)

I say Cameron because I adore her but also because I saw the back of JLo's dress...it's not even close to zipped up all the way. It doesn't fit her at all. There is fabric between the open zippers and tons of bobby pins. I know that she just had twins and she's naturally very curvy, but they couldn't have found a dress that fit her perfectly, especially when the designer was also at the shoot?

j lo looks great on that dress

ARE you SERIOUS? Where are these pictures? I need to see. I also don't like the way she just looks like she quickly pulled her hair back sprayed some hairspray and caked on red lipstick. She looks like back in the day when she was on In Living Color or something.

i chose the bonita boriqua. cam looks to matchy matchy but i like j.lo's nuetral colors put together.

cam looks like little red riding hood and its way unflattering on jen. so neither! but such a cute dress!

MY opinion is that some of you are being a bit harsh. J Lo's body isn't up to snuff after having twins? Are you serious? Genetically, she is not going to be lean without extreme dieting and exercise, but she has a nice shape. This is what "curves" look in two dimension and why models do not have them--bad angles.

Anyway, this dress is too WASPY for either woman.

*this is how curves look

When I mentioned what I felt about J.Lo, yeah I did said body however, her make up is way...the f*ck off. She had her "glam squad". Now her make up looks half ass, her body is flabby(other women look great after having twins) and her hair is all out of place... take a look at jenny three months before she announced she was pregnant and take a look at her now. Don't be delusional and say she looks the same. Then, you'll be lying.

I don't like the dress on either. It looks too department store prom to me. In fact I remember trying one on very similar in my prom season.

PS. That 34th post is giving off some bad energy on realistic body images, seriously. You just gave birth and your expected to go to the gym right after like other psychos, please.

You obviously don't know most pregnant women that Want and WILL do what it takes to get their old bodies back.... Right now she looks a mess, but guarantee you all she'll be fit and toned with in four months! It's not my fault nor is it J.lo's if other women wanna complain their fat asses off instead of doing something about it. Eh...eat a f*cking carrot!

i think jenn gives it a more stylish look as opposed to the very proper boring look cameron gave it, but jenn just looks pretty bad with the red lips,hair, and weight on the arms. she should've opted for a more flattering style at the moment.

This is one of those dresses that can get unintentionally frumpy...figure-wise, I think they both wear it fine, but the accessories screwed it up.

Cameron: love the shoes, lose the shawl.

J Lo: The earrings and shoes both are totally wrong.

They both look cute, but I don't love the dress.

Cameron, hands down!