I'm not crazy about the dress, period. But Vanessa looks better. I hate how Paris is always so matchy-matchy.

Paris does match too often. For someone with so much money and craving to be in the public eye all the time, she has no taste!

I dont like it. Especially on either of them

Neither! I just don't like the dress at all.

I just think it's a cheesy dress, so neither.

I agree... I really am not fond of the dress itself, it's funny like haha funny, but it does look better on Vannessa

i don't like black shoes with a blue dress...

I LOVE the dress. It's a classy patriotic dress. No better way to wear our stars. The blue does look better on Vanessa's skin tone. However, I believe black and blue do not match, in any case, but particularly dark dark/electic blue. Making me go for Paris Hilton looking the best.

Christian Louboutin shoes are an exception to the matchy-matchy rule. Never pass out a moment to perfectly match your Louboutins with your outfit.

They both look fabulous, but Paris is would have to be my choice for THE best because of the shoes.

I REALLY hate that dress.

You know, I never thought I'd say this, but Paris really did it better.

Ehh, I have to say Vanessa, although I'm not crazy about her black shoes or her orangey skin.

I think this dress is cheesy, but Vanessa definitely looks better in it with her curves. Paris's lack of womanly features don't fill it out and makes the supposed to be fitted dress just hang there.

Neither but Vanessa looks the best.. but that's really not saying much.

i don't like this dress. it's so pageant-y and too much for vanessa's bust and it just overwhelms paris, especially with the shoes. i'm usually a huge fan of tracy reese, but this is a rare miss.

the dress is horrible, so NEITHER!! however, because of paris' choice of matching a bright blue dress with BRIGHT BLUE SHOES, it makes the outfit look like a costome... but the black shoes don't go with the dress either. ugh, all wrong, all wrong!

when Paris 1st wore it i didn't understand how did she chose that dress but i didn't know that it can get worse and someone else will get that same dress&wear it!!!! i'm lost now!!!!!
i hate the dress but it looks better on Vanessa

Paris is way to matchy-matchy for me. Anyway, Vanessa fills out the dress better.

I voted for paris only because the hemline on vanessa is too long. It just isn't very flattering.

I don't like Paris style. She look's like she go to 4th of July Parade!!!

the dress is not all that, but it looks better on Vanessa, cause Paris is to skinny for that dress.....
to pull it of, one need some curves...

I don't like black and blue together so I say Paris. I actually don't mind the dress.

Paris is a lot more 'camp' and over the top in her style and stuff, so I think she can pull it off, whereas vanessa, less so

I think that Tracy is a friend of Vanessa's. Vanessa has a better figure, Paris looks like a stick figure.

Not super keen on the dress - and if I IGNORE the shoes, I prefer the fit and shape of it on Vanessa....saying that, I don't like EITHER pairs of the shoes...black looks too heavy and the blue pump just seems silly.

HOrrid dress, but I like Paris' shoes better.

I'm not too fond of the dress either but as to who wore it better I have to say this is my first "both." Vanessa's got curves and it's a nice contrast on her skin. As for Paris: you just cannot go wrong with Christian Louboutins. Extra points for managing to find the same shade, too. As cheesy as it is.

I don't like the dress full stop. On either of them.

It's hard to tell I hate the dress

as much as it kills me to admit liking paris ANYTHING, i actually think the style of the shoe suits the dress better than vanessa's. i hate the blue, but maybe a simple black pump or even a silver slingback would have worked better.

I don't like the dress, but I think I'd really love it in another color, black maybe

it's a bit ridiculous, but if i had to choose, i'd pick vanessa
paris is too kitschy

silver shoes would be much better than black shoes,and matching the dress with blue shoes isn't good either.I think vanessa does wear it better

silver shoes would be much better than black shoes,and matching the dress with blue shoes isn't good either.I think vanessa does wear it better

I HATE THAT DRESS =?

gasp!

i don't like the dress but i prefer it on vanessa- her dark hair and skin tone and dark shoes set it off nicely but also tone it down. paris's super blonde hair and blue shoes are just way too much

Vanessa fills it out better, yet I dislike her black heels. But then, I'm not crazy about Paris Hilton's matchy look. It's just a stupid dress overall and neither makes it look cool.

Paris wins. It looks like Vanessa squeezed into it, it's not very flattering at all.

not feeling the dress

That dress is hideous.

And both of those skanks are pure wh*res. All of America knows that one. So who cares about either slut and what horrible outfit they're wearing this time around.

i wouldnt see why n e one would ant the dress but i picked vanessa cuz she is pretty regardless but i dont agree with the shoes that she is wearing. n with paris there is too much blue the shoes is a no go.

Which wh*re it better? Mm, neither!

The dress seems to hug Vanessas curves better, or maybe it's just because she has curves.

I like it on Vanessa.

the dress is just. stupid.

PH has no taste whatsoever so i don't expect anything better from her. And shame on Vanessa for stooping so low!

it looks very...patriotic