hate it

I would have liked it if the sheer panel was as short as the dress, but no way on that much sheer overlay...

I really can't decide. At first, I hated it. But the more I look at it, I found it growing on me a little. It is very different, but I'm not sure I mind it.

I think she looked fabulous at the event

not a fan of this

hideous.

Ugly! It would have been cute minus the extra sheer fabric. The lengh of the sheer fabric is way too long it actually makes he look old!

I wish there was another option. Because I'm undecided about it. I don't hate it or love it. I just like it.

It looks like crap on her.

Looks cheap and horrible on her.

The bottom part ruined the dress

it's a little "Genie"

it looks like someone stole half of her dress. hate it.

this is so rockin' hehe

I think she looked fabulous. She stood out and didn't look like every other girl her age. At least she's taking a risk and being fashion forward instead of doing the same thing as everyone else all the time.

I love it.

ugh, that's just bad. XP

i would have loved it if it stopped at the miniskirt
but as it is, hate it!

I love it. A short black dress is too boring.

I would have chosen some different shoes though.

hate it. not flattering at all

i think no one wore that dress before i really like it its something new

i like it a lot, its different

Bad proportions

YUK, so so ugly.... to me......

I agree w/ psychobabble- too much sheer at the bottom, should be a little bit shorter.

It's an interesting idea, but bad execution. The sheer panel is too long, the belt makes the fabric bunch at her armpits, the shape of the neckline is weird...

Yuck. I just want to grab a pair of scissors to cut the sheer part at the bottom off.

HATE it.

i like the concept, but something is definitely lost in translation. if the sheer hem was shorter it'd probably be cute, maybe with a cuter collar out of the sheer material too.

Hated it!!! This looks awful. It makes her look shorter than she is - and she is really short as is - not good.

I don't think this is as "chic" as it is plain bizarre.

Oh God... terrible.

This is incredibly unflattering.

I agree with mstrauss.

9.5 out of 10, she gets it wrong.

I like it

what kind of get up is this? it makes her look shorter and sort of like a evil genie.

I love the upper 3/4ths of it, but the sheer lower part is awful. I think she looks great, despite the fact that I can't stand her...

I love it!!!!

the bottom totally killed the dress. someone should have chased her down with a pair of scissors and cut it off...

It's a nightmare.

So ugly.

Looks cheap (belt, shoes, bracelet) and thrown together...not in a good way. Sheer bottom part is too long...like, why is it there? It's not sexy, and she doesn't need to hide her legs. I agree that it makes her look shorter. I think the outfit doesn't compliment but takes the attention off of her, and with the big hair on top it's just all too much. The earrings don't work for me, either. But I think it was an interesting idea, kudos for trying it, and I do like the look of the top, above the too-big belt.