the first girl is ashley tisdale. the second, brittany snow, the third amanda bynes, the fourth vanessa hudgens.

the first girl was said to be vanessa tisdale...but it's ashley tisdale.

Thanks for clarifying elynlovesyou - I got a little confused who's who of these PYTs! xo

Brittany looks fabulous but she should've worn an accesory that never goes out of style -- a smile! (cheeeesy) Amanda also looks great but I do wish she'd tone down the blonde. I actually think she looks amazing with dark hair (ala the bathroom scene in She's The Man) Ashley just looks messy to me, and there's something about Vanessa's look that I don't like, even if I can't explain it.

Ashley's look is my favorite!

I like all the looks except Vanessa's. I do wish Brittany Snow would smile, too. She'd look so much prettier.

That yellow dress is fab!

If I HAVE to chose it would has to be the yellow dress...

I would have said it would be between Ashley and Amanda, but I'm loving Ashley's look here more.

VH

I'm loving Brittany's dress.

I love the yellow dress. The bold shade really catches the eye.

I love them all, really hard to decide. I chose Vanessa though. Brittany does need to smile, Amanda needs to dropthe peroxide bottle, Vanessa looks much older than I think she is and Ashley looks like she is doing something wrong?

i would of voted for brittany but she looks angry so i picked miss v
she's working that dress

I think Vanessa looks the best she looks cute but it doesn't look like she's trying too hard, second would be Brittany. I think Amanda looks like she's going to a highschool dance and I just don't like Ashley's hair and that pose she's doing.

I love the black dress but I love the gold shoes amanda is wearing

Ashley

Amanda and Brittany both look awesome!

I really like the first one, Ashley I guess.

i actually think they all look great except Brittany

I like Amanda Bynes but I think she's too skinny...but then again, who isn't these days in Hollywood?

actually, i liked everyone's outfits except brittany snow.

None. The detailing on Ashley's is ugly close up, zoomed out it looks like Ashley Tisdale - 'nuff said. Amanda, bless her she tries, but the hair is awful and the dress looks like a quilt. Vanessa looks like a badly wrapped Christmas gift and Brittany, as I mentioned elsewhere looks yellow, just really yellow.

Love Brittany's look overall... Tough choice tho...

I like Brittany Snow's Yello Dress! It fits her so well and the color is great.

thatyellow dress looks like the one nicole richie wore to the tonite show... ugm, so she loses cool points 4 that... can anyone find out if it's the same dress? i love the black dress it's stunning!

love the yellow dress!!!

I love Amanda's outfit; The mint green is so pretty.

I like Ashley's dress the best, in terms of which one I would wear myself. But the whole package should go to Amanda, she looks happy to be there, and her hair doesn't suck. She should go back to a darker shade because she looks better not blonde but the rest of the girls' hair doesn't look like they should be on a red carpet.

vanessa

I love Amanda Bynes!

Britney Snow has WAY too much makeup on, she looks trampy. If her makeup was fresher and more age appropriate she would have looked way cuter.

Love Vanessa's dress. It's sophisticated yet edgy. I think it suits her personality perfectly! The next i'd choose is Ashley's. It's got the glam rock vibe, which I love.

Vanessa's look is both cute sophisticated and edgy.Love it.

I'm loving Ashley, Amanda and Vanessa!
But not quite Brittany...
Though i love that yellow
=]
(I voted for Vanessa)

i like vanessa's take on the lbd

Why does Brittany look like a cheap hooker in that pose?!

ummm.brittany who? she looks drugged out and scary. like, meth or cocaine scary. the dress is cute n all, but she looks ugly!!! for that, and for looking cute and sweet, amanda bynes wins my vote (^.^)

I love amanda's and brittany's dress...but my vote was for amanda.

All four girls look very cute. Gosh they are very trendy young girls aren't they? Watch your back LiLo

Brittney's dress looks similar to the one that Reese wore to the Golden Globes. Different cut, but that's what it reminded me of. Empire waists run the risk of making the wearer look preggers, but I like Amanda's dress. It's sweet and she looks good in the pastel colour.

Vanessa

Sheesh, the first 2 blonde girls look almost identical (their faces)!

i don't know who this girls are, so i hope i got the name right with the girl dress i like , so i voted for Vanessa (the girl who wore the black dress).

they all look really adorable

i want to vote for all...where can i get legs like these girls. very jealous over here.

Vanessa-I hate Ashley's dress, hair and pose, Brittany needs to smile more and Amanda should tone down the blonde-ness!!!

I like them all! Initially, Britney's outfit popped out to me the most but that face just threw me off without a smile. I like Vanessa's overall look the best, but all very very cute. I would wear any of it