Quantcast
 

Fab Ad? Sisley Fashion Junkie, 1

Thu, 07/12/2007 - 9:00am by FabSugar
38,086 Views - 87 comments

UPDATE: I have been informed by Sisley's parent company Benetton that these ads are fake. To see the real Sisley fall ad campaign, please visit Sisley.com. Thanks!

OK hold up. Sisley has gone too far with this ad. I normally like Sisley's racy and daring ads but this is too much - too in your face! The line of poking fun has crossed over into inappropriate. This ad is part of a series and if you look at Fashion Junkie, 2, where the fashion vice is alcohol instead of blow, I think that is as far a fashion junkie as Sisley should have gone.

Back in 2004, Benetton owned Sisley was featured in an article about how in France ultra provocative advertising isn't shocking - which is true for a lot of countries - but the US is tighter lipped about such things. While I appreciate sultry imagery and can laugh at a cheeky message, there is a fine line.

There are a couple more things I'd like to point out here. There is some nippleage on the left model - no big whoop really. And, I wonder if Chase Bank is OK with these models using one of their bank cards as a cutting device. As for the clothes, I like the deep purple dress but I really can't focus on anything but the not-so-subliminal message and the weird look in the model's eye. What do you all think?!

Source


87 Comments Add a Comment

  • steen's picture
    steen
    2

    I think it's funny if you consider how many models are actually snorting. But I can see how a lot of people would be offended.

    Then again, isn't the fashion world's job? To offend?

    1 year 13 weeks ago Report Comment
  • LaLaLaurie06's picture
    LaLaLaurie06
    3

    inappropriate and yet another sad message to send the young girls who idolize fashion and those in the industry

    1 year 13 weeks ago Report Comment
  • tuffghost's picture
    tuffghost
    4

    I love this for the same reason why I love Lindsay Lohan. It's straight-up, in your face, and doesn't apologize or try to cover anything up. I think it's genius.

    1 year 13 weeks ago Report Comment
  • trace face's picture
    trace face
    5

    I think it's trying to hard, and pretty stupid to boot.

    And, is it just me or does it say FASHIOIN Junkie, and not Fashion?? Maybe the freakin ad execs who designed this one are snorting one too many lines themselves. LOL

    Stupid all around...

    1 year 13 weeks ago Report Comment
  • crispet1's picture
    crispet1
    6

    Inappropriate and the clothes arent the highlight of the photo.

    1 year 13 weeks ago Report Comment
  • razzlemoon's picture
    razzlemoon
    7

    i'm just not a fan...coke is a serious problem and the media/fashion industry brush over it, hide it and choose to let it grow. i love fashion, but i don't love the message this is sending.

    1 year 13 weeks ago Report Comment
  • whiskeyrogue's picture
    whiskeyrogue
    9

    even as a graphic designer, i think this is going too far... little girls will look at these glossy layouts and think that this is something to aspire to? sad.

    1 year 13 weeks ago Report Comment
  • klynnmorton's picture
    klynnmorton
    10

    Now, I am sorta torn.
    First, I think that photography and fashion are both art forms, and because of this, I think that being critical about the appropriateness or morality of a piece of art is both small-minded and pointless.
    HOWEVER, this is not JUST art, it is also ADVERTISING, where companies do have a duty to put positive images, especially about drug use, into the minds of our young people.
    So, while I appreciate the art of it, I do feel as though the images are inappropriate for mainstream media.

    1 year 13 weeks ago Report Comment
  • MissBardot's picture
    MissBardot
    11

    This isn't glamorous and it's totally inappropriate. The model in the purple looks disgusting.

    1 year 13 weeks ago Report Comment
  • cg2003's picture
    cg2003
    13

    i personally don't think anything of it, but i'm thinking about the 12 year old girls who go online or see this in a magazine and think this is cool

    1 year 13 weeks ago Report Comment
  • Brians Girl's picture
    Brians Girl
    14

    i personally like it alot! actaully.. but i could see how there are many ppl out there who would be very offended by this.. but its pretty sweet!!.. fashion junkie haha

    1 year 13 weeks ago Report Comment
  • retail_therapy's picture
    retail_therapy
    15

    it is very inappropriate though i get the point of their campaign..but it isnt in very good taste. nice make-up though

    1 year 13 weeks ago Report Comment
  • Lovaajn's picture
    Lovaajn
    16

    I'm all of artistic expression, and I'm no nazi - if you wanna do drugs, do 'em. I don't, so it's not my problem. However, I think promoting it, or even imitate in a joking sense," we all know it's a prevalent problem in the modeling world...and it's probably not a good idea to show it in some kind of mass advertising. I think it's definitely tacky and improper.

    1 year 13 weeks ago Report Comment
  • glam sugar's picture
    glam sugar
    17

    Isn't coke a big enough problem already, especially in fashion?

    This is pretty tasteless.

    1 year 13 weeks ago Report Comment
  • Seraphim's picture
    Seraphim
    18

    i completely agree whiskey
    lame=sad=whatthellhasthisworldcometo=ohwellitstolateanyway

    1 year 13 weeks ago Report Comment
  • nyc_gal's picture
    nyc_gal
    19

    i'm not a fan though i wasn't really shocked by it in any way. as advertising it's not that effective since the only thing i can focus on is the model's blank stare. this would be more appropriate in an art gallery in which case i would definitely like it

    1 year 13 weeks ago Report Comment
  • nyaradzom2001's picture
    nyaradzom2001
    20

    Benetton has always pushed the envelope when it comes to advertising but this is just tacky and stupid I don't know what's worse the Gucci one with the guy pulling down the girl's underwear revealing a G waxed onto her coochie or this one. Nah no contest this one wins hands down.

    1 year 13 weeks ago Report Comment
  • mommie's picture
    mommie
    21

    Agree, bad message. glamourising drug use is not a good example to send.

    1 year 13 weeks ago Report Comment
  • pinkflats's picture
    pinkflats
    23

    i think what has been going on with in the Fashion world recently: Kate getting caught snorting coke, too skinny models, models dying, etc. the Fashion world really need to direct theirselves to a new direction.

    i have a feeling that until a huge, influential model dies from drugs (not going to name names but i have a feeling you guys might have a clue) that's when the fashion world will rethink their priorities but for now i don't see them changing which i think is really sad.

    1 year 13 weeks ago Report Comment
  • myownworstcritic's picture
    myownworstcritic
    24

    Since so many advertising campaigns today target tweens and teens, this is highly inappropriate! Adults can laugh it off but kids probably will make the associate of high fashion with high times. We parents have enough to worry about, my negative reaction to this ad will factor into my buying decisions.

    1 year 13 weeks ago Report Comment
  • davie_k's picture
    davie_k
    25

    Addiction of any kind is not a laughing matter, and especially drug use. This is just glamorizing drug use and abuse. I'm european and even I would be shocked to see this advertising campaign!

    1 year 13 weeks ago Report Comment
  • swwonder's picture
    swwonder
    26

    It seems like so much of fashion photography is an attempt to make some sort of controversial point. So much so that they loose focus of what they're trying to do - sell clothes/accessories etc.

    1 year 13 weeks ago Report Comment
  • pinupsweetheart's picture
    pinupsweetheart
    27

    This isn't right. Girls that look coked out as it is with a credit card with white poweder? What kind of message are they trying to push??

    1 year 13 weeks ago Report Comment
  • pennylane's picture
    pennylane
    29

    i completely disagree. to say the drug ad is going too far but the alcohol ad is ok is ridiculous. and probably would be insulting to someone with an alcohol problem. "poking fun" at an alcohol addiction is ok but implying a drug addiction is not?

    1 year 13 weeks ago Report Comment
  • Chica8a's picture
    Chica8a
    31

    i dont like the ad at all .. fashion and drugs ... dont mix those too please

    1 year 13 weeks ago Report Comment
  • evita's picture
    evita
    32

    it is defintley racy and not my cup of tea, but they did get the attention they wanted and people talking about them, so in the end maybe it is really good advertising!

    1 year 13 weeks ago Report Comment
  • BowerySugar's picture
    BowerySugar
    33

    My only problem with it is that it might send the message that drug usage is to be treated laxly. Other then that it's boring

    1 year 13 weeks ago Report Comment
  • cmachter1's picture
    cmachter1
    34

    I have to say..I was shocked when I saw it. Very very in your face. Everyone's postings here have pretty much summed up how I feel about it. It's not appropriate for young girls...or recovering addicts by "glamourizing" it. But it is effective advertising..as it has everyone talking about it...even though I would refer to the ad in conversation as "the models that were snorting the "cocaine" dress".

    1 year 13 weeks ago Report Comment
  • rc630's picture
    rc630
    35

    I think its really tacky
    Not cool, guys.
    Don't do drugs.

    1 year 13 weeks ago Report Comment
  • high d's picture
    high d
    38

    hahah i can't believe they did that sh*t, and theres a credit card on the side, to cut what? FASHION? AND SNIFF IT?

    1 year 13 weeks ago Report Comment
  • madhatter's picture
    madhatter
    41

    What the hell. They spelled fashion with an extra 'i.' It's all the damn coke.

    What a ridiculous ad - too bad they couldn't get Kate Moss. Then it would have been ironic, and I wouldn't be so mad that they can't effing spell their OWN AREA OF EXPERTISE.

    Haha, fashioin.

    1 year 13 weeks ago Report Comment
  • Bellatrix's picture
    Bellatrix
    42

    I like this ad for its part of truth and irony.
    I like this ad for the genius mixture : there are a lot of fashion addicts out there.
    I like this ad for the giggle shock I got out of it.
    I like this ad because I'm French maybe? That article was a bit of a surprise to me. I didn't know France was singled out for advertising. Then again, I can't remember many cocaine scandals or huge sex parties going on in our country...

    1 year 13 weeks ago Report Comment
  • nicachica's picture
    nicachica
    43

    sigh...that's just disappointing that some highly paid ad exec can't use his/her creativity and will just resort to models "snorting" a coke dress. not only is it stupid and offensive, but it lacks originality and reminds me of the "Heroin Chic" era of the mid-90's.

    1 year 13 weeks ago Report Comment
  • karen f's picture
    karen f
    45

    I don't agree with advertisement glamorizing drugs and addiction. This isn't the first ad I've seen lately that makes drugs sound like a fun and cool thing to do.

    1 year 13 weeks ago Report Comment