I chose Miranda but Samantha is a close second minus the sneakers. I can't imagine what Charlotte was doing. If I were her I would have refused to wear that.

i voted for miranda because i love how it does compliment her fiery red hair, plus her dress is simple but sophisticated enough that it's not too boring. moreover i like that dress, though would def stand out from the rest, it doesn't compete for attention as much as charlotte's dress with the bride's dress.

oooooh! what's carrie wearing?

i voted miranda.. that bright blue looks amazing against her hair and fair complexion.

Miranda, that color is perfection on her.

I voted for Miranda, she looks amazing. I just don't know what to say about Charlotte, I love her, but I don't think that dress looks good on her at all..

charlottes looks awful

I think only Miranda looks good is because of the way the photos were taken. So maybe Samantha could have looked better. As for Charlotte, I don't know what to say :\

That color looks wonderful on Miranda. Charlotte's dress looks nice but it could've done without the necklace. Posen's a genius.

they all look FABULOUS!

Samantha looks the most natural in her dress.

Charlotte's makes her look a little hippy.... Does anyone else think this? Maybe it's just the way shes holding her arms .

Miranda.

I chose Miranda, but don't agree with the comments. I'm not so sure about it complimenting her hair, that is, but I love the dress on her.

I bet Charlotte's scene is one where her actual dress gets torn or something wretched happens to it. Well, not bet, hope.

I chose Samantha but they all three are hideous.

Miranda

OMG!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
is saw what carrie was wearing in the newspaper!
total spoiler and i kinda wish i hadnt seen it but....!

Miranda by a landslide. That dress looks beautiful on her. Charlotte's dress is...unfortunate to say the least.

The blue dress has the best cut and looks goergous, so I voted for it.
However, the red dress must be hard to wear for a blonde, but Samantha looks awesome in it as well.

Miranda definitely looks the most FAB.
I found out on ANTM that blue complements red hair/fair skin tones.

What do you mean red dress must be hard to wear for a blonde? Red dresses and blonde hair goes together like peas and carrots!

The red dress is too crazy with the ruffles, though. All I can think when I look at that thing is "Ruffles! Ruffles! Everywhere!" Same problem with the bottom of the black dress. The blue one is the only one that doesn't let the ruffles take over the dress.

Miranda. Definitely.

Kristin Davis is gorgeous, why did they have to spoil it by letting her wear that weird creation? Miranda looks fab!

All these dresses are so gross in my opinion. The fabric makes them look cheap and the black one looks like it was made out of that stuff they wrap reese's peanut butter cups in.

I agree bp99, Charlotte looks REALLY hippy! And that necklace just kills it. Yeuch!

Miranda wins, by loads!

And Lenina... the answer to your question is, ack... you don't wanna know!

Bad, just bad

Love Miranda's dress

Miranda.

What the hell is Charlotte wearing? Ew.

i must say miranda's colour of dress works REALLY well with her hair colour. Yah, what the heck is Charlotte wearing?

What is going on with this movie?! I know SATC had a big effect on women's fashions but why are they taking it up ten notches? The outfits so far we have seen look so distracting even in a NY background!

Miranda's and Charlotte's are amazing esp. Miranda's, so great on her! Don't like Samantha's

Yeah Charlotte is slightly pear shaped, and as a pear shaped woman all I can say is I would have thrown a hissy fit until they changed my dress.

Miranda!

thats 2 much for me

i love the ornate structure of charlotte's but find something slightly off. it just doesn't seem to fit her... miranda is stunning! her ensemble is the most flattering by far.

well, i think miranda looks great in that color, but the shape of the red dress is better

Miranda, hands down!

Samantha looks like she's entering "Dancing with the Stars". And Charlotte's about to go trick or treating.

Miranda FTW. That shade of Blue is striking!

that colour of blue is perfect on miranda. not sure if it's just the picture, but charlotte looks quite large in her dress and she is definitely not a big person. samantha was a close second for me, her dress fits her really well.

Ok, I saw another pic of Charlotte that was very lovely, but this is off. Doesn't this look kinda distorted like one of those fun house mirrors to anyone else? That photo is off.

Charlotte looks awful in this pic. But in other ones that I've seen of her in this dress, she looks just beautiful. But I still think Miranda looks better.

I voted Miranda. Charlotte's dress is like nails on a chalkboard. Hideous. & P.S. All I see are her arms and they look really bad in the photo. Not toned at all. You'd think she would be rock solid given this is THE movie for her.

miranda! cuz can i just say that this movie is finally upping her in the style stakes!

blue, miranda all th eway but the reds nice too. Black is yucky

blue, miranda all th eway but the reds nice too. Black is yucky

Miranda's dress is best one, Samantha's is pretty nice too I think, Charlotte no comment.

Miranda