in my opinion there is no competition here...ASHLEY !!!

They look so wrong on Nicole. In my opinion, they don't go with her outfit at all. Ashley uses them to give something extra to her look and it works for her. I'm not a fan of these shoes but Ashley makes them look good!

I think Nicole looks kind of ridiculous in them. But Ashley wears them perfectly.

I love them, by the way. I can't wait until someone comes out with a knockoff.

i think they are the worst. i especially HATED it when nicole attempts to perform in them, not that the girl can't work a pair of heels, but this may be far exceeding her capabilities... if i HAD to pick it would be ashley though

ashley wins

CL Studded Booties should take the center stage for your outfit, not compete with it. So, Ashley wins this one by a landslide.
That being said, I think they are pretty ugly. Love CL's, just not these.

Yea I say Ashley is the winner!

ilk...they are fugly

I agree. The shoes are detailed enough and should be the center of attention. And they really clash with Nicole's dress.

they don't like right on either person

Neither... UGLY shoes!

Ashley! I love her style. Who is the other girl?

yuck...I cant get past how ugly they are in the first place!
Neither!

these are the first pair of louboutin's that i don't like

the boots are just sooooo ugly. They don't match anyone's outfit...

I'm usually a fan of louboutins...but this is just too much.

UGH neither...so ugly..

Nicole's outfit makes no sense with those shoes. Ashley isn't better but at elast she matches.

ugh, i think those are horrendous

ashley for sure.

this pair of shoes is wicked! i like it better in MK but somehow all that excess jeans around the ankles there isnt very flattering.

I prefer the loub studded Mary Janes though.

These boots are so gross.

Are those not the EXACT same boots that Madonna wore in "Desperately Seeking Susan?"

Ashley wore it better, without doubt.

they look good with Ashley's outfit!

Those boots do not go with Nicole's Alexander Wang dress AT ALL! Did she get dressed in the dark?

I agree with most people here. Ashley wins.

Who the hell told Nicole that these boots matched her outfit? She looks ridiculous. Ashley definately pulls them off, but for a stylish brand like CL, they are NOT the best boots that i have seen, and i would not wear them.

Ick! Sooo Desperately Seeking Susan.

Those boots are horrible!

Ashley

i cant think of anyone who will pull it off

except Gwen stafani

those are UGLY shoes, i voted neither

ashley!

nicole looks a mess.

Neither...the shoes are just sooo ugly.

They both look good

These boots prove that even the divine Monsieur Louboutin can have an off day.
They are ghastly, like something The Black Knight would wear to go jousting in.

those shoes are hideous

Olsen, obvi.
The boots are really cute, but Nicole makes them look totally skanky.

Those were made by Louboutin for the Olsen twins. No one else can pull them off. WORK it Ashley!!

I like them both!
Buuuuutttt I chose Nicole just because I think she looks more WOW!

Not my fave pair of Loubs, but I think Ashley pulls them off much better than Nicole. I like Nicole's dress, but what was she thinking pairing those booties with it? Scroll-down fugly. Ashely's simple look is a much better idea when you have something so busy going on on the feet.

Ashley all the way!!

Ashley

The shoes go better with AShley's outfit.

Ashley is always fabulously chic.

i hated them when i saw them on nicole, somehow ashley makes them work