ashley

I think the scarf is just too bulky.

I like Ashleys overall look - its a bit more original than Sienna's and Kate's - But they all look GREAT

Kate, Kate, Kate! Ashley is great, too, such style, but Kate is the original and she's always just right.

Ashley's colors are the best but none of them WEAR it the best, in my opinion

Usually I would say Kate, because I loveeee her and her style, but I really like the colors of Ashley's!

None of them. They all look like crap to me.

I like...SIENNA! She looks hawt mama!

I like Sienna's look best.

I'm also going to have to go with Sienna

love ashleys scarf...anyone know who makes it???

I am scarf-obsessed this season...these all look cute but Ashley wins it for me out of the three.

Sienna! She looks strikin!

i heart ashley's!!! it's how i would wear it

Kate, definitively.
She's my girl-crush, while Sienna is close behind too.

Oh! Did Kate get a new hair cut?

Sienna. I love her style.

:vomit:

Sorry none

sienna just has the whole look going on

Ashley. Love her style.

None of them. They all look terrible!

Sienna.

Although I'm not a huge fan of any of them.

kate

Kate looks like she's blowing her nose in a rag.
And, although I adore Ash, red leopard print I do not.

I don't really know much about Sienna but she looks nicely put together, however, the sunglasses HAVE to go!

Kate- Sienna just looks like a ripoff of Kate, and I can't take the Olsens seriously.

its a scarf, no one can go wrong with that. All three looks fine to me.

Say what you will about Sienna's personal life (I know I have, hehe) but I love her fashion sense. She always owns her looks and looks completely confident in whatever she wears. She looks best in the scarf.

Sienna!

Kate, obviously. Ashley and Sienna are wearing horrible shoes. I mean, I know we're discussing the scarf, but the overall impression must be important as well. Kate is also much better at making colours match - the other two don't seem to have given that any consideration.
(Love her Mulberry-bag as well...)

Kate!!! She looks so like me (only blonde!) in this outfit! I wore something that looks so like this! Only my scarf is turquoise, magenta & lilac...

Ha! I just bought a leopard print scarf recently and had no clue that it was so much as a "trend". I guess just about everything in stores can be classified somehow as a trend. It's certainly not the first time that I've read after the fact that something I bought was a trend.

Sienna! But the other 2 cool!